Assistant Professor, Mennonite College of Nursing, Illinois State University, US
Copyright © 2023 Korean Academy of Community Health Nursing
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution NoDerivs License. (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/4.0) which allows readers to disseminate and reuse the article, as well as share and reuse the scientific material. It does not permit the creation of derivative works without specific permission.
Conflict of interest
The authors declared no conflict of interest.
Funding
None.
Authors’ contributions
Kim, Jung Eun contributed to conceptualization, formal analysis, methodology, project administration, visualization, and writing - original draft, review & editing.
Data availability
Not applicable.
Author, Year | Purpose | Design | Participants | Geographic location | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cha, 2012 | To explore potential factors affecting the self-care behaviors of Korean immigrants with T2DM | Qualitative | Korean immigrants (n=20) | Atlanta, Georgia, U.S. | Identified three major ideas: (1) issues on treatment regimen related to medications & diet (2) resources that helped or hindered their ability to manage diabetes (3) physician-patient relationship |
Female=11, male=9 | |||||
Age: 52-76 | |||||
Chesla, 2009 | To describe cultural & family challenges to illness management in Chinese immigrants with T2DM & their spouses | Qualitative | 20 foreign-born Chinese American couples (n=40) | San Francisco | Diabetes symptoms challenged family harmony. Dietary prescriptions challenged food beliefs & practices. Disease management requirements challenged established family role responsibilities. |
Age: 35-75 | |||||
Chesla, 2014 | To explore gender differences in factors associated with diabetes management with behavioral intervention in Chinese immigrants | Quantitative | Chinese immigrants with T2DM (n=178) | San Francisco, Chinatown | Chinese women immigrants reported significantly poorer self-assessed general health & depression (p< .5), and tended to have greater total diabetes distress, emotional burden, and interpersonal distress (p < .1). However, statistically significant gender differences were not found for diabetes self-efficacy, family conflict, and family emotional support. |
Age: 51-70 | |||||
Choi, 2015 | To identify domains of spousal support in diabetic self-care | Qualitative | Korean immigrants with T2DM (n=16), spouses (n=17), (total n=33) | Orange County, California | Six domains identified: diet, exercise, emotional support, medical regimen, communication with clinicians, & information. Diet was the most frequently described across all groups. Individualizing spousal support and recognizing diabetes management as teamwork is an important elements of successful spousal support. |
Age 60↑ | |||||
Chun, 2011 | To examine how acculturation affects T2DM management and perceived health for Chinese immigrants in the U.S. | Qualitative | Chinese immigrants from China or Hong Kong (n=19) | San Francisco | Three key themes were identified: utilizing health care, maintaining family relations and roles, and establishing community ties and groundedness. |
Age: 52-71 | |||||
Chun, 2016 | To examine effects of bicultural efficacy, or perceived confidence in dealing with bicultural acculturation stressors, on T2DM management and health for Cantonese-speaking Chinese immigrants | Quantitative | Chinese immigrants (n=162) | San Francisco Bay area | Longer diabetes diagnosis duration was related to greater DQOL-S and using insulin was related to higher DQOL-I. Proxy and general acculturation measures and social support were significantly related to DQOL-S and DQOL-I. Proxy and general acculturation measures and social support were not significantly related to diabetes distress. |
Age: 51-70 | |||||
Hu, 2013 | To explore perceived barriers among Hispanic immigrants with diabetes and their family members | Qualitative | Hispanic immigrants with T2DM (n=73) | Barriers to diabetes self-management were in 3 major themes categorized as: suffering from diabetes, difficulties in managing the disease (difficulty & frustrations taking medications, hard to control diet, difficulty with exercise), and lack of resources/support. | |
Age: 49-61 | In North Carolina | ||||
Iten, 2014 | To investigate the relationship b/t immigration status and the patient experience of health care, DM self-management, and outcomes among Mexican immigrants with diabetes. | Quantitative | Mexican immigrants with T2DM (n=401) | In two immigration sanctuary cities: San Francisco Bay & Chicago | There were no statistically significant differences b/t three groups (US-born, documented, undocumented) on physician trust or reports of positive physician communication. Diabetes self-care behaviors did not differ b/t the three groups. Documented and undocumented are 1.2 and 1.2 times more than US-born to perceive higher level of these barriers to diet and medication adherence. |
Age: 37-66 | |||||
Joo, 2016 | To explore barriers & facilitators of diabetes self-care among Korean senior immigrants with T2DM | Qualitative | Korean elderly immigrants with T2DM (n=23) | Five perceived barriers: the high cost T2DM care, language barriers, loss of self-control, memory loss, & limited access to healthcare resources. | |
Age: 66-71,. | Midwest | Three facilitators: time, seeking information, & family & peer supports | |||
Kindarara, 2017 | To describe Sub-Saharan African immigrants’ health illness transition experience r/t T2DM self-management. | Qualitative | Sub-Saharan African immigrants (n=10) | Sacramento County, California | Four overarching domains were identified: knowledge of T2DM self-management behaviors, current T2DM self-management behaviors, inhibitors of T2DM self-management, and facilitators of T2DM self-management |
Age: 44-76 | |||||
Magny-Normilus, 2020 | To explore and describe the lived experience of adult Haitian immigrants with T2DM in the U.S. | Qualitative | Haitian immigrants (n=16) | Northeastern | Four themes were identified: self-reliance, spirituality, nostalgia for home, a desire for positive patients-provider relationships |
Age: 40-63 | |||||
McConatha, 2020 | To examine how aspects of culture, social support, isolation, & loneliness are perceived as influences in T2DM or pre-diabetes among Middle Eastern immigrants. | Qualitative | Middle Eastern immigrants (n=28) | Philadelphia area | All participants reported increased feelings of isolation, loneliness because the illness requires many lifestyle changes. Avoiding traditional ethnic food can be highly stressful. Identified themes: 1) vulnerability, anxiety, & stress associated with making lifestyle changes, 2) relationship & social support challenges, & 3) Cultural disconnection, loneliness, & social isolation |
Immigrants from Iran, Turkey, and Lebanon | |||||
Age: 60-80 | |||||
Nam, 2013 | To examine challenges in diabetes self-management among Korean immigrants with T2DM | Qualitative | Korean immigrants with T2DM (n=23) | Social stigma. Diabetes management is not always a top priority for Korean immigrants over other family obligations or financial stability in their busy immigration lives. Conflict with family members in managing diabetes or would not request support from family member for diabetes care. Korean women are more vulnerable to a lack of self-care. Lack of English proficiency limits access to mainstream health care | |
Age: 30-75 | U.S. | ||||
Njeru, 2016 | To assess diabetes knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors of Somali and Latino immigrants with T2DM | Quantitative | Somali and Latino (n=78) | Rochester, Southeast Minnesota | Respondents reported that diabetes had significant social impacts on normal activities, including travelling, physical activity, food and relationships. Among Latino participants, cost was noted to be a significant barrier to diabetes care. |
each group 39 | |||||
mean age: 52 | |||||
Park, 2016 | To evaluate the components of East Asian DM self-management interventions. | Mixed-study review | Articles (n=16) | U.S. | From 9 qualitative studies, two overarching themes were identified including cultural beliefs and immigration-related challenges. |
Immigrants from China, Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan | |||||
Age: 55-65 | |||||
Smith-Miller, 2016 | To describe the quantitative findings of a mixed-methods study that examined the relationship among knowledge, self-efficacy, health promoting behaviors, and T2DM self-management among Spanish-speaking Hispanic immigrants | Mixed-methods study | Hispanic immigrants (n=30) | U.S. | Participants were not effectively managing diabetes. The results based on three SEM models suggest that effective intervention strategies need to focus on improving knowledge, nutrition, and physical activity, reducing stress, and leveraging the importance of interpersonal relationships. |
Age: 27-86 |